Big is Slow
Subhead – The holding-company model is creaking under its own weight, and Irish brands should be watching
The advertising industry is entering a period of tectonic realignment. What reads like consolidation fever among the global holding companies is less a sign of renewed strength and more an admission that the old model is under sustained pressure. That argument, set out by James Dunne in an opinion piece for AdWorld, lands hard: big is slow, and slow is becoming irrelevant. (See James Dunne, AdWorld). https://www.adworld.ie/2026/05/08/opinion-the-new-indie-agency-moment/
Numbers and momentum
Dunne points to hard numbers that suggest decline is structural, not cyclical. At one major network, headcount fell 14.6 percent between 2016 and 2023 while sales slid 5.3 percent. Another has managed only 1.6 percent annual revenue growth over 15 years. Three of the so-called Big Six are effectively flat or shrinking. Those are stark statistics to hang an industry narrative on, and they explain why merger talk – Omnicom buying IPG or large-scale reshuffles at WPP – reads less like aggressive expansion and more like panic management. For context on those groups see Omnicom and WPP.
In-house and indies changing the economics
Clients are voting with their procurement strategies. Dunne cites figures showing 64 percent of brands now run some form of in-house creative, and 70 percent manage programmatic strategy internally. Those shifts reduce the leverage once held by large agencies and force a reassessment of where value sits. The consequence is a clear opportunity for independent agencies – lean, specialist shops that can combine creativity with speed – to pick up work the giants no longer do so efficiently.
The indie resurgence is not a PR stunt. Survey numbers quoted in the piece suggest 86 percent of independent agencies expect growth in 2025, and 90 percent are partnering with other agencies to scale globally without surrendering autonomy. The new model is federation not acquisition; networks are being built from the ground up by agencies that want control, not into portfolios that are centrally managed. The growing role of private equity in backing this movement further blurs traditional ownership lines and creates capital-backed alternatives to the public-holding route.
The AI multiplier
One of the most compelling claims in Dunne’s analysis is that AI acts as a force multiplier for small teams. Where once production scale required hundreds of people and multiple layers of sign-off, a 20-person indie with the right tooling can now rival the output of a 200-person legacy shop. Examples cited include indies cutting launch times dramatically and delivering cost efficiencies to large clients. That does not mean holding companies will disappear overnight. They will invest, buy technology firms, and create AI studios. But scale cannot easily fix workflow bloat, internal politics, or a balance sheet built on yesterday’s economics.
Culture, talent and the pitch for relevance
Beyond tooling, culture matters. Talent is increasingly motivated by the promise of real ownership, a clearer career arc and a less bureaucratic working environment. Dunne points to the example of smaller agencies winning marquee creative outcomes – a reminder that creative reputation can be won outside London or New York, and that winning the work often depends on agility as much as pedigree.
What brands should consider
For brand leaders in Ireland and beyond the choice is not between safety and bravado. It is between convenience and performance. Big agencies still offer breadth, global reach and a perceived safety net. But those benefits come at a premium and increasingly with slower decision cycles. Indies offer speed, direct access to senior talent, and the latest in automation. The sensible play for many procurement teams may be hybrid relationships – retain large partners for scale where necessary, and build long-term strategic relationships with smaller specialists for innovation and speed.
A pragmatic checklist for procurement teams
– Treat indies as strategic partners, not stopgap vendors.
– Insist on clear KPIs and fast feedback loops.
– Test AI-enabled delivery in low-risk pilots before wider roll-out.
– Use networks of trusted specialists to replicate scale without adding bureaucracy.
Where this leaves the holding companies
The holding companies are too big to collapse quickly. They have cash, global footprints and institutional clients. But relevance is not guaranteed. Margins will come under pressure if clients shift more work in-house or to specialist partners. The long game for big groups is adaptation – streamlining decision-making, decentralising authority, and truly integrating technology rather than treating it as a marketing line item.
Conclusion – The market of 2030
Dunne’s conclusion is blunt and useful for business readers: the future belongs to speed, not size. Ireland’s advertisers and marketers should be clear-eyed about the trade-offs. Safe choices may look conservative today but could cost market share tomorrow. For indies this is an opportunity; for brands it is a moment to rebalance suppliers and insist on measurable outcomes.
Source and further reading
Opinion piece by James Dunne, AdWorld – www.adworld.ie – https://www.adworld.ie/2026/05/08/opinion-the-new-indie-agency-moment/
More on the major groups mentioned – Omnicom Group (https://www.omnicomgroup.com/) and WPP (https://www.wpp.com/)
Related Posts
- Asus Launches Competing Secondary Touchscreen Display to Rival Elgato
- Key Takeaways from Oireachtas Online Safety Committee Hearing
- Lennon Named Co-Chair of Balance for Better Business Initiative
- Mizuho Raises Alphabet Price Target as Google Cloud Growth Outlook Improves
- Media Awards 2026 Winners Revealed: Full List & Standout Winners

